A Minimal Entropic Derivation of MOND-like Gravity Motivation Verlinde (2016) proposed that de Sitter space contains a volume-scaling entropy associated with dark energy. Matter removes part of this entropy. Beyond a critical scale, the remaining volume entropy dominates and produces an apparent dark gravitational component. Peach (2019) reformulated the idea using an entropic-screen construction. The argument below combines these ideas and fixes the force normalisation using Verlinde's spherical response coefficient. Competing Entropies For a sphere of radius $r$, the de Sitter entropy is $$S_{\rm DE}(r) = \frac{r}{L}\frac{A(r)c^3}{4G\hbar}, \qquad A(r)=4\pi r^2,$$ while a central mass $M$ removes $$S_M(r)=\frac{2\pi Mc}{\hbar}r.$$ Thus $S_{\rm DE}\propto r^3$ and $S_M\propto r$. Define $a_\Lambda=c^2/L$. Their ratio is $$\frac{S_{\rm DE}}{S_M} = \frac{a_\Lambda r^2}{2GM} = \left(\frac{r}{r_c}\right)^2,$$ where $$\boxed{r_c=\sqrt{\frac{2GM}{a_\...
$\Lambda$CDM and Holographic Dark Energy Holographic dark energy (HDE) starts from a simple thought: the energy inside a region of size $L$ shouldn't exceed that of a black hole of the same size. Saturate that bound, up to a dimensionless number $c$ (not the speed of light), and $$\rho_{\rm DE}=3M_p^2\frac{c^2}{L^2}, \qquad\text{i.e.}\qquad c=HL\sqrt{\Omega_{\rm DE}}.$$ Units $\hbar=k=1$, $M_p^2=1/8\pi G$, prime $=d/d\ln a$, flat universe, $\Omega_X=\rho_X/3M_p^2H^2$. Li's Model In Li's 2004 model, $L$ is the future event horizon , the farthest a light ray sent today will ever get: $$L_e=a\int_t^\infty\frac{dt'}{a(t')}, \qquad \dot L_e=HL_e-1.$$ Li took $c$ constant, giving $w_{\rm DE}=-\frac13\left(1+\frac{2\sqrt{\Omega_{\rm DE}}}{c}\right)$. And this is where the problems begin. With $c=1$ and $\Omega_{\rm DE,0}=0.6889$, $w_0=-0.887$, about $5\sigma$ from Planck 2018 $w_0=-1.03\pm0.03$. Does not match observations! And any constant $c<1$ gives $w<...